I think they originally intended to give it the same treatment as Real Love…by speeding up the demo in an effort to brighten it up…hence the caposBDJ wrote: ↑Sat Feb 17, 2024 11:30 am Another thing they did was to change the pitch of John's vocals. Perhaps that is a reason he sounds different from the demo.
His piano was out of tune; in 1995, they used capo's on their guitars to 'detune' their guitars (see the photo's), but in 2023 they didn't need them anymore. I suppose they used AI to change the pitch of John's voice, and may have introduced some 'autotune' in that process.
Now And Then (merged threads)
- Rickenbacker325
- Posts: 538
- Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2021 10:29 pm
- Location: The Dingle
- Has thanked: 202 times
- Been thanked: 108 times
Re: Now And Then (merged threads)
-
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Sat Apr 10, 2021 7:44 am
- Has thanked: 5 times
- Been thanked: 14 times
Re: Now And Then (merged threads)
I thought that too until I read the "Sound and vision" article that was shared in this topic, it says the original demo was somewhere between Am and B flat minor.Rickenbacker325 wrote: ↑Sat Feb 17, 2024 3:37 pmI think they originally intended to give it the same treatment as Real Love…by speeding up the demo in an effort to brighten it up…hence the caposBDJ wrote: ↑Sat Feb 17, 2024 11:30 am Another thing they did was to change the pitch of John's vocals. Perhaps that is a reason he sounds different from the demo.
His piano was out of tune; in 1995, they used capo's on their guitars to 'detune' their guitars (see the photo's), but in 2023 they didn't need them anymore. I suppose they used AI to change the pitch of John's voice, and may have introduced some 'autotune' in that process.
Pitch correction, he notes, was also made worse by the fact that John’s piano was slightly out of tune. [He determined, later, that “Now and Then” was actually in A minor, though the tape played it in between B flat minor and A minor,
So it might have been why they have capos, without really speeding it up (or just very slightly to get to B flat minor).
Last edited by dannysonar on Sun Feb 18, 2024 8:12 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Lord Reith
- Posts: 4784
- Joined: Thu Feb 18, 2021 8:22 am
- Location: BBC House
- Has thanked: 158 times
- Been thanked: 4305 times
Re: Now And Then (merged threads)
Yes, when I did my version of N&T I remember playing the piano part in A Minor.
However the type of piano John is playing is what I call an "old banger", and they are very often tuned sown a semitone, so it's altogether possible it's meant to be in Abm. Come to think of it his voice does sound a little weedy.
Autotune is the Botox of the audio world. If you're not looking closely it can give the fleeting illusion of perfection, but as soon as you scrutinize it in any detail the stiffness becomes apparent. The same as Botoxed faces give me an uncanny valley feeling, so do Autotuned voices. I actually prefer the flat-out massively autotuned vocals on today's stuff to the mildy autotuned vocals of people like Adele. Because at least the former is obviously fake, but the latter attempts to pull the wool over people's eyes.
However the type of piano John is playing is what I call an "old banger", and they are very often tuned sown a semitone, so it's altogether possible it's meant to be in Abm. Come to think of it his voice does sound a little weedy.
Autotune is the Botox of the audio world. If you're not looking closely it can give the fleeting illusion of perfection, but as soon as you scrutinize it in any detail the stiffness becomes apparent. The same as Botoxed faces give me an uncanny valley feeling, so do Autotuned voices. I actually prefer the flat-out massively autotuned vocals on today's stuff to the mildy autotuned vocals of people like Adele. Because at least the former is obviously fake, but the latter attempts to pull the wool over people's eyes.
Women there don't treat you mean, in Abilene
Re: Now And Then (merged threads)
'Now and Then' campaign chronology
2023.10.25 Cassette Teaser
2023.10.26 TheBeatles.com announcement
2023.10.26 'Now and Then - The Last Beatles Song' Trailer
2023.10.26-11.02 BBC Sounds: 'Eras' Podcast
2023.10.29 Teaser 'Come together for the last Beatles song, 2nd November'
2023.11.01 "Now and Then - The Last Beatles Song" premiered at BBC The One Show (Paul intro #1)
2023.11.01 "Now and Then - The Last Beatles Song" available on YouTube and Disney+
2023.11.01 Teaser 'From Liverpool to New York to Tokyo. Come Together tomorrow, 2nd November'
2023.11.02 BBC Radio 'PM' - Annie Nightingale
2023.11.02 Single available on streaming
2023.11.02 BBC, iHeart Radio, SiriusXm World Premiere (Paul intro #2)
2023.11.02 Paul's interview with Clara Amfo (recorded on 2023.10.28)
2023.11.03 "Now and Then - The Music Video" premiered (Paul intro #3)
2023.11.04 BBC 'The Beatles & The BBC' documentary
2023.11.10 BEATLEMANIA IS BACK! Number 1 UK Single
2023.11.10 'Now and Then' clock story
2023.11.21 YouTube An Orchestral Celebration of 'Red' and 'Blue'
2023.11.24 'Now and Then' campaign in Mexico City
2023.12.24 Instagram Season's Greetings
Let's see what happens at the 2025 Grammys, Emmys and Oscars
2023.10.25 Cassette Teaser
2023.10.26 TheBeatles.com announcement
2023.10.26 'Now and Then - The Last Beatles Song' Trailer
2023.10.26-11.02 BBC Sounds: 'Eras' Podcast
2023.10.29 Teaser 'Come together for the last Beatles song, 2nd November'
2023.11.01 "Now and Then - The Last Beatles Song" premiered at BBC The One Show (Paul intro #1)
2023.11.01 "Now and Then - The Last Beatles Song" available on YouTube and Disney+
2023.11.01 Teaser 'From Liverpool to New York to Tokyo. Come Together tomorrow, 2nd November'
2023.11.02 BBC Radio 'PM' - Annie Nightingale
2023.11.02 Single available on streaming
2023.11.02 BBC, iHeart Radio, SiriusXm World Premiere (Paul intro #2)
2023.11.02 Paul's interview with Clara Amfo (recorded on 2023.10.28)
2023.11.03 "Now and Then - The Music Video" premiered (Paul intro #3)
2023.11.04 BBC 'The Beatles & The BBC' documentary
2023.11.10 BEATLEMANIA IS BACK! Number 1 UK Single
2023.11.10 'Now and Then' clock story
2023.11.21 YouTube An Orchestral Celebration of 'Red' and 'Blue'
2023.11.24 'Now and Then' campaign in Mexico City
2023.12.24 Instagram Season's Greetings
Let's see what happens at the 2025 Grammys, Emmys and Oscars
Re: Now And Then (merged threads)
Not sure if anyone else has heard this yet, but the song apparently features in the recent movie "Argylle". I haven't seen it yet, so I can't say what they use of the Beatles version (which I think might be in there as well), but here's the orchestral version from the soundtrack.
Here's an article on it: https://www.kshe95.com/real-rock-news/h ... n-argylle/
Here's an article on it: https://www.kshe95.com/real-rock-news/h ... n-argylle/