Re: Wrong Masters for the ‘Glyn Johns 1969 Mix’, and Japan came to rescue.
Posted: Sun Oct 24, 2021 7:40 pm
Beatleg Database Forums
https://forum.beatlegdb.com/
A question: aren't the channels inverted on that version?powerPC wrote: ↑Sun Oct 24, 2021 7:40 pmGeorgeD is correct... FYB on the Reddit is the correct 1969 mix, additionally the other tracks seem to be less compressed than the ROW version.
The stereo image is reversed compared to the boots, but it is the correct mix.Martin85 wrote: ↑Sun Oct 24, 2021 8:10 pmA question: aren't the channels inverted on that version?
I mean, the vocals are good, but the piano is on the left. It's that ok?
It looks like the Reddit version is legit. In addition to having the correct mix of For You Blue, there are a lot of other differences. Several of the track lengths differ from the ROW CD version. This post http://webgrafikk.com/blog/news/wrong-m ... he-rescue/ describes a lot of what those differences are. The Reddit files are consistent with waveforms and track lengths posted here and with spectrogram images posted on Hoffman that show a comparison between the different versions, like the distinct edit points on the ROW CDs. Maybe someone who has a confirmed version of the Japanese CD will verify for sure at some point.
Totally agree. It's not a sonic wonder.Suzy Parlourphone wrote: ↑Sun Oct 24, 2021 10:16 pmIt looks like the Reddit version is legit. In addition to having the correct mix of For You Blue, there are a lot of other differences. Several of the track lengths differ from the ROW CD version. This post http://webgrafikk.com/blog/news/wrong-m ... he-rescue/ describes a lot of what those differences are. The Reddit files are consistent with waveforms and track lengths posted here and with spectrogram images posted on Hoffman that show a comparison between the different versions, like the distinct edit points on the ROW CDs. Maybe someone who has a confirmed version of the Japanese CD will verify for sure at some point.
The Japanese version has a lot more brickwall limiting throughout than the ROW CD version. I don't think dynamic range values are the be all and end all necessarily, but they are definitely worse for the Japan SHM. I find it kind of interesting that it's starting to get a reputation for being the "better" version. It is interesting to hear the variations, like the different For You Blue vocal, but I'm not sure it's really preferable from an audio standpoint.
Code: Select all
<equalizationeffect>
<curve name="1970 eq_AV">
<point d="-3.3691876404472114" f="23.910373259012676" />
<point d="-3.5206812266172576" f="24.763148302139495" />
<point d="-3.620647982039649" f="25.646337980215844" />
<point d="-3.6786536274925954" f="26.561027045928345" />
<point d="-3.720785918755298" f="27.508338940193575" />
<point d="-3.751648398684734" f="28.48943717199254" />
<point d="-3.7733244746893764" f="29.50552674741758" />
<point d="-3.7760544375915446" f="30.55785564968699" />
<point d="-3.7451141396742926" f="31.647716371944945" />
<point d="-3.6824476726607056" f="32.77644750472966" />
<point d="-3.5955076447905605" f="33.945435380059195" />
<point d="-3.4868212649009336" f="35.15611577415455" />
<point d="-3.3607475175682566" f="36.409975670891015" />
<point d="-3.2158955268626728" f="37.708555088144" />
<point d="-3.046869856968468" f="39.05344896927239" />
<point d="-2.8342333655545686" f="40.446309142062404" />
<point d="-2.5811958064800304" f="41.88884634753836" />
<point d="-2.332352163739054" f="43.38283234113171" />
<point d="-2.1246831207182604" f="44.930102068789644" />
<point d="-1.9617907235720857" f="46.53255592069519" />
<point d="-1.8215335814173685" f="48.192162065367775" />
<point d="-1.699428906823032" f="49.91095886701026" />
<point d="-1.6119045574626685" f="51.69105738907209" />
<point d="-1.5789395772788068" f="53.5346439871032" />
<point d="-1.5836463659860816" f="55.443982994083036" />
<point d="-1.636611207509975" f="57.42141950152358" />
<point d="-1.7538017377327777" f="59.469382239761345" />
<point d="-1.9105241966542583" f="61.59038656097671" />
<point d="-2.0526650373460376" f="63.78703752860374" />
<point d="-2.165698515696276" f="66.06203311692576" />
<point d="-2.2678720811793665" f="68.4181675247856" />
<point d="-2.35654954074604" f="70.85833460748114" />
<point d="-2.418458976596048" f="73.38553143106114" />
<point d="-2.4481823377285497" f="76.00286195338651" />
<point d="-2.476222090890581" f="78.71354083647877" />
<point d="-2.4937518461604107" f="81.52089739483739" />
<point d="-2.480991558935928" f="84.42837968457602" />
<point d="-2.4299073897116346" f="87.43955873839951" />
<point d="-2.340143099794231" f="90.55813295162396" />
<point d="-2.2419783867893956" f="93.78793262462557" />
<point d="-2.137135681007785" f="97.13292466729861" />
<point d="-2.0742275433714803" f="100.59721747130017" />
<point d="-2.0407794997979534" f="104.1850659560657" />
<point d="-2.003273116711754" f="107.90087679479296" />
<point d="-1.9422715909691433" f="111.7492138268139" />
<point d="-1.9312951190071543" f="115.73480366300053" />
<point d="-1.9398164750712352" f="119.86254149109111" />
<point d="-1.9433558631914263" f="124.13749708806517" />
<point d="-1.9769591232276924" f="128.56492104695414" />
<point d="-2.0309950977057185" f="133.15025122573263" />
<point d="-2.0918186641839966" f="137.8991194262142" />
<point d="-2.0794044065356374" f="142.81735831115145" />
<point d="-2.0848577228008556" f="147.91100856803914" />
<point d="-2.0964743089063766" f="153.18632632841724" />
<point d="-2.127985491626995" f="158.6497908517873" />
<point d="-2.1008920406016145" f="164.30811248357932" />
<point d="-2.056981124796434" f="170.16824089694288" />
<point d="-2.0312546420387334" f="176.23737362848675" />
<point d="-2.004666410905923" f="182.52296491844862" />
<point d="-1.9553967665276755" f="189.03273486615515" />
<point d="-1.8883013592123934" f="195.77467891201405" />
<point d="-1.9030286687613647" f="202.7570776576882" />
<point d="-1.8670879696444362" f="209.9885070365092" />
<point d="-1.815500527717305" f="217.47784884662514" />
<point d="-1.7583041044681111" f="225.23430165981583" />
<point d="-1.7191342700872327" f="233.26739211937988" />
<point d="-1.6576091575640666" f="241.58698664096292" />
<point d="-1.60464486596596" f="250.20330353070298" />
<point d="-1.537969224427128" f="259.1269255355765" />
<point d="-1.517796860862675" f="268.3688128413559" />
<point d="-1.528017330738383" f="277.9403165341482" />
<point d="-1.463583385622561" f="287.85319254204364" />
<point d="-1.4320783122150778" f="298.11961607400195" />
<point d="-1.4284797345816345" f="308.75219657370747" />
<point d="-1.4053040648334085" f="319.7639932067608" />
<point d="-1.379036493896939" f="331.1685309002285" />
<point d="-1.3513537304215983" f="342.97981695425244" />
<point d="-1.3039436677208764" f="355.2123582461181" />
<point d="-1.2815239067508284" f="367.8811790479152" />
<point d="-1.207942848125719" f="381.00183947967497" />
<point d="-1.1427148109668743" f="394.59045462064546" />
<point d="-1.1213290606832527" f="408.66371430218203" />
<point d="-1.0681332973113817" f="423.23890360655844" />
<point d="-0.977365833566707" f="438.3339240968795" />
<point d="-0.9214438966639869" f="453.96731580416963" />
<point d="-0.869400207191668" f="470.1582799986385" />
<point d="-0.8235077779485727" f="486.9267027730982" />
<point d="-0.786302918743395" f="504.293179467493" />
<point d="-0.7504032907149466" f="522.2790399645412" />
<point d="-0.7269241242113782" f="540.9063748875585" />
<point d="-0.7004804323911207" f="560.1980627326418" />
<point d="-0.6303070845842561" f="580.1777979685322" />
<point d="-0.5932147623999211" f="600.8701201386738" />
<point d="-0.5966926871300663" f="622.3004440012146" />
<point d="-0.55484113387439" f="644.4950907439611" />
<point d="-0.5094459301580639" f="667.4813203126297" />
<point d="-0.4677521955888125" f="691.2873648921048" />
<point d="-0.4222735275529905" f="715.9424635818202" />
<point d="-0.37726600433886087" f="741.4768983078512" />
<point d="-0.31644790497399555" f="767.9220310158347" />
<point d="-0.2595996390817044" f="795.3103421903887" />
<point d="-0.24355191203500598" f="823.6754707483447" />
<point d="-0.1902757525236609" f="853.0522553547972" />
<point d="-0.12028021671045136" f="883.4767772127059" />
<point d="-0.0718464007568056" f="914.9864043786091" />
<point d="-0.013575536158834611" f="947.6198376588826" />
<point d="0.04041421995469219" f="981.4171581429031" />
<point d="0.10365889175483145" f="1016.4198764315125" />
<point d="0.16511262320052222" f="1052.6709836212385" />
<point d="0.1922862188606569" f="1090.2150041068908" />
<point d="0.2410064280551666" f="1129.0980502673808" />
<point d="0.3219295341298264" f="1169.367879101953" />
<point d="0.3760311937115245" f="1211.0739508863574" />
<point d="0.4350246611184613" f="1254.2674899210363" />
<point d="0.5052322617736589" f="1299.0015474459144" />
<point d="0.578063436218147" f="1345.3310667990859" />
<point d="0.6455804885049974" f="1393.3129508994089" />
<point d="0.7090336943347519" f="1443.0061321359053" />
<point d="0.7676892446569665" f="1494.4716447497922" />
<point d="0.8669174628300187" f="1547.7726997980621" />
<point d="0.9468751428059021" f="1602.9747627906718" />
<point d="1.0206432001605128" f="1660.145634096696" />
<point d="1.1063205768086313" f="1719.3555322182137" />
<point d="1.1919414639196635" f="1780.6771800341905" />
<point d="1.2585522152413902" f="1844.1858941202902" />
<point d="1.3268975934417429" f="1909.9596772543323" />
<point d="1.4007347257702183" f="1978.0793142209843" />
<point d="1.4677489625259599" f="2048.628471033381" />
<point d="1.567582365658491" f="2121.6937976935483" />
<point d="1.630655829631756" f="2197.365034617798" />
<point d="1.7111876514146984" f="2275.7351228578564" />
<point d="1.790974922694528" f="2356.900318253072" />
<point d="1.8613507794637631" f="2440.9603096539317" />
<point d="1.942567011523552" f="2528.0183413620466" />
<point d="2.0143990916899943" f="2618.181339937063" />
<point d="2.07942348688218" f="2711.5600455261533" />
<point d="2.1229711875429658" f="2808.269147877488" />
<point d="2.1622277570407498" f="2908.427427204654" />
<point d="2.1778307520819404" f="3012.1579000750767" />
<point d="2.172330506641048" f="3119.587970501649" />
<point d="2.186669705859768" f="3230.849586423086" />
<point d="2.1569175961463065" f="3346.079401765247" />
<point d="2.1415669020167343" f="3465.418944282447" />
<point d="2.102916680408547" f="3589.014789384906" />
<point d="2.04867114853091" f="3717.0187401658413" />
<point d="2.003386786302956" f="3849.5880138493176" />
<point d="1.9795081326335902" f="3986.8854348878435" />
<point d="1.9072166606373575" f="4129.079634946872" />
<point d="1.8849110765894328" f="4276.345260021903" />
<point d="1.840885441443434" f="4428.863184942445" />
<point d="1.7954042647969235" f="4586.820735526411" />
<point d="1.7442050133629365" f="4750.411918657739" />
<point d="1.7495032783646365" f="4919.8376605698395" />
<point d="1.7010432770871438" f="5095.306053627562" />
<point d="1.6783680513793726" f="5277.032611910743" />
<point d="1.6631914373850865" f="5465.240535913247" />
<point d="1.6165974302335098" f="5660.160986682661" />
<point d="1.6517877911815833" f="5862.033369737312" />
<point d="1.5838003575175663" f="6071.10562910927" />
<point d="1.572442206855733" f="6287.634551874613" />
<point d="1.5214877357187224" f="6511.886083544847" />
<point d="1.5212952562964637" f="6744.135654706971" />
<point d="1.439890303764994" f="6984.668519313256" />
<point d="1.3886669069556346" f="7233.780105036367" />
<point d="1.415378550462785" f="7491.776376119961" />
<point d="1.4066076449324072" f="7758.974209170693" />
<point d="1.426111896515594" f="8035.701782352824" />
<point d="1.3592120644445542" f="8322.29897846381" />
<point d="1.3493333845171687" f="8619.117802385708" />
<point d="1.3343584045925279" f="8926.522813425176" />
<point d="1.2788619521892228" f="9244.891573073115" />
<point d="1.2543712683762542" f="9574.615108733866" />
<point d="1.2759236986715403" f="9916.098393993563" />
<point d="1.3197590075168952" f="10269.760846017394" />
<point d="1.2437877739647032" f="10636.03684068693" />
<point d="1.218791154950006" f="11015.376246109885" />
<point d="1.1595973789366496" f="11408.244975157995" />
<point d="1.1771524696118885" f="11815.125557711199" />
<point d="1.1821071661085194" f="12236.517733311308" />
<point d="1.1835502668627809" f="12672.939064952936" />
<point d="1.1569710214521667" f="13124.925574765588" />
<point d="1.1445734382954404" f="13593.03240236763" />
<point d="1.0979029535729037" f="14077.834486700795" />
<point d="0.997984795621784" f="14579.927272182656" />
<point d="0.9351171831427143" f="15099.927440044303" />
<point d="0.7743776873629706" f="15638.47366575167" />
<point d="0.5741775936374576" f="16196.22740344048" />
<point d="0.27882120001760924" f="16773.873698328593" />
<point d="-0.09914405215484234" f="17372.122028103367" />
<point d="-0.585172188897741" f="17991.7071743175" />
<point d="-0.8737851583959388" f="18633.390124863665" />
</curve>
</equalizationeffect>
Circulating anyWhere ???????? Or just a Myth ???Lord Reith wrote: ↑Sun Oct 24, 2021 2:26 am The "1969 Recordings" album uploaded by Apple and Calderstones Productions to Spotify a couple of years ago probably gives us an indication of what was on early versions of the set. If you subtract the GB album from "Total Time" that leaves two roughly one hour cds (which might have been Discs 3 & 4 at one point)
The Beatles: 1969 Recordings
Total Time: 2 Hours 37 Minutes
1. One After 909 - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (3:06)
2. I'm Ready - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (0:45)
3. Save The Last Dance For Me / Don't Let Me Down - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (1:16)
4. Don't Let Me Down - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (4:09)
5. Dig A Pony - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (4:04)
6. I've Got A Feeling - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (2:53)
7. Get Back - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (3:14)
8. For You Blue - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (2:46)
9. Teddy Boy - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (3:41)
10. Two Of Us - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (3:29)
11. Maggie May - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (0:38)
12. Dig It - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (4:24)
13. Let It Be - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (3:53)
14. The Long And Winding Road - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (3:43)
15. Get Back - Reprise - 'Get Back' LP May 1969 (0:41)
16. All Things Must Pass - Rehearsal 3 January 1969 (3:58)
17. I Me Mine - 8 January 1969 (1:37)
18. Suzy Parker (aka Suzy's Parlour) - 9 January 1969 (2:07)
19. Oh! Darling - Paul's Solo Performance (4:18)
20. Don't Let Me Down - 22 January 1969 (3:30)
21. Two Of Us - 24 January 1969 (3:19)
22. I Lost My Little Girl - 24 January 1969 (2:14)
23. For You Blue - Take 1 / 25 January 1969 (2:23)
24. For You Blue - Take 3 / 25 January 1969 (2:30)
25. For You Blue - Take 4 / 25 January 1969 (2:49)
26. For You Blue - Take 11 / 25 January 1969 (2:36)
27. For You Blue - Take 13 / 25 January 1969 (2:34)
28. Let It Be - 26 January 1969 (3:43)
29. Medley: Rip It Up / Shake, Rattle And Roll - 26 January 1969 (2:10)
30. Medley: Kansas City / Miss Ann / Lawdy Miss Clawdy - 26 January 1969 (3:56)
31. Blue Suede Shoes - 26 January 1969 (2:12)
32. I Told You Before - 26 January 1969 (5:48)
33. The Walk - 27 January 1969 (0:53)
34. I've Got A Feeling - 27 January 1969 (3:36)
35. Get Back - 27 January 1969 (3:49)
36. Dig A Pony - 28 January 1969 (3:58)
37. Something - 28 January 1969 (8:59)
38. One After 909 - 29 January 1969 (3:25)
39. Medley: Cannonball / Not Fade Away / Hey Little Girl / Bo Diddley - 29 January 1969 (4:25)
40. Mailman, Bring Me No More Blues - 29 January 1969 (1:31)
41. Get Back - First Roof Performance 30 January 1969 (4:24)
42. Get Back - Second Roof Performance 30 January 1969 (3:34)
43. Don't Let Me Down - First Roof Performance 30 January 1969 (3:30)
44. God Save The Queen - Roof Performance 30 January 1969 (0:25)
45. I've Got A Feeling - Second Roof Performance 30 January 1969 (5:31)
46. Don't Let Me Down - Second Roof Performance 30 January 1969 (3:33)
47. The Long And Winding Road - 31 January 1969 (3:53)
48. All Things Must Pass - George's Demo (3:50)
49. Something - Take 37 (3:01)
© 2019 Apple Corps Limited
℗ This Compilation ℗ 2019 Calderstone Productions Limited (a division of Universal Music Group)