Engonoceras wrote: ↑Sun Nov 20, 2022 2:10 pm
millerTEK wrote: ↑Sun Nov 20, 2022 9:25 am So it makes you wonder - what was the bootleg's source as when that appeared in the 90s, they didn't remix and reconstruct a Take 1 and then a Take 2 with vocals..right, why would they do that? I now think the bootleg source having the vocals on THEIR Take 2 meant their source was probably the recording of Take 3 with vocals - in which that take also included the queuing of the false start from Take 1, too.
The released song is take 2 with overdubs. Overdubs did not get new take numbers once they went to 4-track.
The bootlegged version is a rough stereo mix of take 2 with all four tracks of the 4-track turned up.
The Revolver DE version is simply just track 1 of the 4-track turned up (other 3 tracks muted).
The first draft of the Anthology 2 CD was actually going to include a vocals only mix of "Paperback Writer" but they dropped that.
Thank you for the clarification of the session! I examined the various releases of these takes and overdubs in my collection and finalized on these versions:
Paperback Writer (tk1, w/stereo chat) (Four Sides Of The Circle, Revolver-Valkyrie Records VAL-013)
Paperback Writer (tk2, backing) (2022 Super Deluxe Edition)
Paperback Writer (tk3) [tk2+overdubs] (Unsurpassed Masters Vol. 3-Unique Tracks)
The 2022 SDE cuts off most of the pre-tk1 chat, does not let the ending play out and does not include the bleed from the other tracks, so you need all three versions.
Tracks duplicating this same material that went into the crapper (201MB
):
Paperback Writer (tk1-2 (S2S+UT) (Great Scott! It's... The Beatles-MasterJedi).flac
Paperback Writer (tk1-2) (Entomology, upgrade).flac
Paperback Writer (tk1) (4/13/66) (Four Sides Of The Circle, Revolver-Valkyrie Records VAL-013).flac
Paperback Writer (tk1) (Complete Recording Sessions-coltturkey 2017).flac
Paperback Writer (tk1) (Revolver Super Deluxe Edition, RalseiDeltarune).flac
Paperback Writer (tk1) YD SS Vol4 (stereo) (Revolver Studio Sessions, Back To Basics-V1 Beta, Helter Skelter).flac
Paperback Writer (tk2 [fake] Instrumental) (Revolver Super Deluxe Edition, RalseiDeltarune).flac
Paperback Writer (tk2) (Anthology Expanded Edition-VooDoo Records).flac
Paperback Writer (tk2) (Ultra Rare Trax-2010).flac
Paperback Writer (tk2) YD SS Vol4 (stereo) (Revolver Studio Sessions, Back To Basics-V1 Beta, Helter Skelter).flac
Paperback Writer 3 (4/13/66) (Four Sides Of The Circle, Revolver-Valkyrie Records VAL-013).flac
Paperback Writer 7 (4/14/66) (Four Sides Of The Circle, Revolver-Valkyrie Records VAL-013).flac